When Gear took the photo, she was in the process of investigating the reports of shadow figures that have been filed by those visiting over the years.
Many paranormal experts believe that these shadow figures are the souls of the 94 executed men and 36 homicides that are linked to the dark building.
The Penitentiary went out of commission in 1995, and nine years later this fascinating paranormal image was snapped as Polly was making her way down a hallway, to the cafeteria.
She later claimed that the figure seemed like a black static entity that had a humanoid shape. She shone her torch at it and the beam of light seemed to cut straight through it’s body.
The entity looked down at the light that cut through it’s body, as if it knew what the result would be.
Gear didn’t panic or freak out – she calmly drew her camera from her bag and managed to snap this now infamous photograph.
She was gradually retreating from the shadow figure when she used her camera, and when she lowered it from her eye-level…the entity had disappeared.
The Debunking Attempts Begin…
The image of the shadow man hit the internet within a matter of days…and with that the debunking attempts began to crawl out of the woodwork.
Eventually the popular paranormal television show, Ghost Hunters, got involved, and claimed that they had successfully debunked the image.
They pointed out that someone had merely shone a IR light behind Polly, creating a shadow man image out of her actual shadow.
Unfortunately, their debunk was then debunked itself – turns out the crew of Ghost Hunters are not as clever as they think (no big surprise there!).
They indicated that Polly was 10 – 40 feet away when she took this picture, and created the fake shadow man image. Experts who then examined the photo pointed out that Polly was actually over 100 feet away from the entity in the picture.
This means that there is no way the shadow could have been this size – it would have been A LOT larger.
Now it’s over to you…
Do you believe the flimsy attempts of a debunk by the Ghost Hunters team?
Maybe they were simply jealous that Polly had managed to capture such a fascinating paranormal entity?
Please leave your thoughts and opinions on the Moundsville Penitentiary shadow man, in the comment section below.
In this article we will be taking a look at the Greenbrier ghost story from 1897, and the dreams that surfaced after Elva Zona Shue was found dead in her West Virginia home…
Mary Jane Heaster began having heartbreaking dreams a month after she buried her daughter, Elva Zona Shue, in 1897. In these dreams, Zona called out to her mother and told her that her death was not from natural causes – she had been murdered.
She pinned the blame on her husband – Erasmus (Edward) Stribbling Trout Shue. She claimed that the fickle man had lost his temper and ended her life because she had not managed to provide him any meat with his dinner.
He then apparently broke his wife’s neck.
The ghost of Zona demonstrated the injury in the dream – by turning her head around 180 degrees (Exorcist style!).
The heartbroken, and angry Mary Jane, went to the local prosecutor at once…but understandably, he did not really believe her ghostly dream story.
She was persistent though, and managed to get him to agree to exhume her daughter’s body and perform a thorough autopsy…
She was right – Zona was found to have a broken neck…she had been murdered.
Elva ‘Zona’ Heaster was born in Greenbrier County, West Virginia, in 1873. She had led a simple life right up to the point where she managed to get pregnant, out of wedlock, in 1895.
In those days this kind of thing was BAD news – nobody wanted to marry a ‘loose woman’ with poor morals, and a kid in tow.
However, she got lucky when a guy named Edward Stribbling Trout Shue moved into the area – he was looking for a new start in life, and didn’t really care that Zona had a child.
On October the 20th, 1896, the lovestruck pair were married…but Zona’s mother, Mary Jane, never really approved of Shue as a husband.
The couple seemed extremely happy in their new life – for three short months…
On January the 23rd, 1897, the body of Zona Heaster Shue was discovered at her home by a young boy running errands. She was found in a heap at the bottom of the stairs, as if she had tripped and fallen.
By the time the local doctor arrived at the house, Shue had moved his wife’s body upstairs to their bed, and had dressed her in a high-neck frock. When the doctor tried to examine the body he was continually interrupted by the sobbing Shue.
Whenever the doctor attempted to examine the head area of Zona’s body, Shue would suddenly cradle the head, and tell the doctor to leave them alone.
The doctor eventually listed her death as an ‘everlasting faint’ that was linked to childbirth…although he had no idea if the girl was indeed pregnant or not!
When Mary Heaster was finally able to convince the county prosecutor to reopen the case – she was already sure in her own mind that Edward Shue had killed her daughter.
The prosecutor did a thorough job of visiting all of Zona’s neighbors and friends in the area, and they all agreed with Mary Heaster’s claims of murder.
When the exhumation was set to take place, Edward was told he would have to be present…he then knew that the game was up, and he informed the prosecutor that he was about to be arrested.
Zona was found with a broken windpipe, and deep finger marks on her neck. Her vertebrae was dislocated and the ligaments torn.
Edward Stribbling Trout Shue collapsed in a heap – he knew the game was up, and he was arrested on the spot.
The later investigation found out that the mysterious Edward Stribbling Trout Shue had been married twice before he arrived in Greenbrier. His first wife had left him, due to the constant beatings he gave her…and his second wife died under mysterious circumstances.
Edward Shue was found guilty of murder on July the 11th, 1897, and sentenced to life imprisonment (he somehow managed to escape the death penalty). He was imprisoned at West Virginia State Prison where he died three years later.
If you have any thoughts or opinions on the Greenbrier ghost story, please leave them in the comment section below.
Dominating the skyline of the small town of Moundsville like a great baronial castle, this massive and imposing prison must have filled those who entered it with dread.
Now corroded and crumbling it has lain empty for the past twenty years, the prisoners shipped out to other penitentiaries or released back into the community.
For those who now expect the empty halls and corridors to echo with the sound of silence, there is disappointment. Far from a peaceful ruin, this prison with its gory and disturbing history is now home to the Moundsville Penitentiary ghosts and they are not going to go quietly.
A Brief History
The little town of Moundsville is an intriguing place, named after the burial mounds found all over the town, it is clearly a place of spiritual importance. Built by the Edina tribe over 2000 years ago on mystical ley lines.
Fast forward to the nineteenth century and this small town in West Virginia was chosen to house either a new university or prison.
Bizarrely the townsfolk chose to build the penitentiary and placed it firmly in the bosom of their community, directly opposite one of the most prominent burial mounds in the town.
Opened in 1866, the Moundsville Penitentiary was destined to become one of the most notorious prisons in U.S. history.
For the next 130 years what followed was abhorrent to most people. Overcrowded and housing some of the most dangerous criminals in the country, Moundsville was often a horrific place for its inmates.
With a regime of torture and cruelty imposed by the management and a dog eat dog attitude amongst the prisoners themselves, life was hard.
Over 998 recorded homicides took place during its history. Add to this number the executions and those who died a natural death and it is small wonder that rumours of hauntings surround the prison.
By the 1990’s things had reached boiling point. Overcrowding, riots and an expose in a national publication, forced the closure of the penitentiary. The remaining prisoners were moved out leaving behind the once great building to slowly fall apart.
There is a belief among prison inmates that if you die in prison, your soul remains in prison. Those that visit the Moundsville Penitentiary can certainly testify to its eerie atmosphere and almost palpable ghostly presence.
Over the years as the evidence of paranormal experiences piles up a number of ghostly hotspots have been identified…
The Wagon Gate: The oldest part of the prison and the place where hangings took place as a form of execution until the electric chair took over. The trap door can still be seen in the ceiling of the building.
Rumor has it that the local townspeople would stand below when there was a hanging. As if it wasn’t a cruel enough punishment, at least two of the hangings went dramatically wrong.
The first, the hanging of Frank Hyer, put an end to public executions. Frank was a heavy man and somehow his weight was miscalculated. As he dropped through the trap door he was decapitated by the noose around his neck.
The hanging of Avril Paul Adkins also went drastically wrong when he fell from the rope and landed on the floor below. The unsympathetic prison staff merely picked up Adkins and re hung him.
One of the most interesting facts about this area is that it was cleaned by the female prisoners after an execution. One of these female prisoners is known to be the mother of Charles Manson.
Visitors to this area claim to have heard sobbing, felt themselves touched or seen strange mists and orbs. The rotating gate that admitted inmates to the prison is also said to turn on its own without anybody operating its mechanism.
The Boiler Room: The boiler room is one of the most haunted parts of the prison. Said to be haunted by a prisoner called R.D. Wall also known as the maintenance man, visitors to the hole have seen strange faces appear on the walls and a green mist swirling about the room.
Wall was rumored to be a snitch within the prison. He was given the job of caring for the boilers for his own protection as it kept him separate from the rest of the prisoners.
Unfortunately a group of inmates bribed some prison officers to gain access to Wall. Left alone with their victim they hacked him to death with knives they had manufactured themselves.
The Sugar Shack:The Sugar Shack is a recreation area within the prison. It is not known whether any homicides took place here but it is certainly a place where violent assaults and rapes occurred.
The area was used during times of bad weather and was left largely unsupervised by the prison staff. People who visit this area claim it is impossible to walk through without bumping into things. When the lights are turned on, the room is always empty.
The Infirmary: Prisoners near death were said to be shipped out to hospital to avoid dying in prison. Most prisoners in the penitentiary believed the myth that if you died in prison your soul remained there forever.
Obviously, there were times that prisoners couldn’t be moved quickly enough. Their souls are now thought to haunt his area. Witnesses claim to have heard crying and moaning in this area.
The Infirmary also has a psychiatric ward where lobotomies were performed on prisoners. As well as screaming the clear sound of a gunshot can sometimes be heard.
The North Hall: The North Hall or the Alamo as it was known, housed the maximum security prisoners. At least three ghosts are said to haunt this area.
The first Red Snyder, murdered and cut up his father before hiding him under the bed. While in prison the dangerous criminal became the leader of the Aryan Brotherhood.
Leaving his cell one day he was stabbed by a fellow inmate Rusty Lassiter. People who have visited his cell have felt a finger brush the back of their neck. Two former employees of the prison also swear that they have heard his voice when visiting the prison.
One lady claims that she heard his voice say “Good morning Mags” while the other says that when she informed the empty cell that Rusty Lassiter had been released from prison, she heard the clear reply “I know”.
The second ghost thought to haunt the area is Danny Lehman. A highly talented artist, Lehman’s work can be seen around the prison. A member of a motorcycle gang he was stabbed through the eye in a revenge attack.
Another ghost who frequents the North Hall is Harry Powers. Powers was the inspiration for the film and book Night of the Hunter. Executed in the fifties, his is the only unmarked grave in the prison cemetery, the reason is unknown.
The Hole: A tiny space leading to the Sugar Shack, prisoners who were locked in here often went mad. Screaming and crying has been heard emanating from this area.
The Shadow Man: The shadow man is perhaps the creepiest of all the Moundsville ghosts. Caught on camera and video he is clearly a powerfully built male figure.
Lacking substance or features but recognisable as a man he has been seen in different areas of the prison. Those who have caught a glimpse of him have first felt eyes boring into the back of their head before turning quickly to catch a glimpse.
Ancient burial grounds, ley lines, murder and suffering. It seems that everything came together to create a perfect storm when Moundsville built its first and last prison.
Some have even suggested that an Indian curse lies on the land. What is for sure is that over a thousand deaths occurred in this unhappy place.
Many of the inmates imprisoned believed that if they died in prison their souls would remain forever, it seems they’re right. Whatever the truth of the matter there is certainly something very sinister and unexplained happening.
For those that tour the now empty prison the answer is clear, the souls of many who lived and died in this awful place are still incarcerated. Murderers and rapists in life, in death they are the Moundsville Penitentiary ghosts.