Was Carole Compton a Witch?

Was Carole Compton a Witch?

In this article we will be taking a closer look at the case of Carole Compton and her employment as a nanny with two Italian families…who firmly believed that she was a witch who was bringing all manner of dark events into their homes…


Carole Compton found love in the form of an Italian man who was passing through her hometown of Ayrshire in Scotland in 1982. He was completing a British placement for his military service, and on his way back to Italy.

Compton was completely in love, and decided to move to Italy so she could be close to him when he finished his military responsibilities.

As soon as she arrived in Italy she found a job as a nanny within days of settling down…

Carole Compton and her Italian Man

The Ricci Family

Carole’s first employers were the Ricci family, and she settled into her new position, and career direction, with relative ease…

Until one day, as she was walking past a religious painting in the home, it mysteriously fell to the floor and smashed. One of the Ricci Family’s maids was on hand to witness the incident…

Unfortunately for Carole, this maid had been brought up in a strongly religious family, and she began voicing concerns over Carole’s soul. She told the heads of the Ricci family that Compton immediately sank to her knees and prayed as soon as the painting hit the floor – as if this sort of thing had happened to her before.

Just days later Carole accompanied the Ricci family when they went to their holiday home in the Italian Alps. Over the period of the holiday visit, three fires broke out in the Alps home.

A investigation on the property took place and the Ricci family were informed that the fires were down to an electrical problem at the home…but the Ricci family were not convinced…and ended up firing Compton just days later.

The Tonti Family

Carole got lucky, and within a matter of weeks after her sacking from the Ricci family, she found employment with the Tonti family, who lived in their grandparent’s home on the island of Elba.

During the first few months of her job, Carole seemed to fit right in with the family’s lifestyle…but unfortunately this did not last…

All of a sudden Carole began complaining to certain members of the Tonti family about strange scratching noises following her around the property. She also seemed to be responsible for the destruction of numerous religious statues throughout the home.

Grandmother Tonti had seen enough, and began to call Carole a “Strega” or witch.

The rest of the family seemed to take Carole’s side, and told the grandmother she was being a ridiculous old superstitious fool…but all this changed when a fire eventually broke out in the bedroom of the Tonti’s three year old child.

When the police looked into the incident they noticed that Carole Compton had been linked with strange fires at her previous post as a nanny (with the Ricci family), and she was promptly arrested.

She ended up spending sixteen months in lockup as she waited for her trial to take place (for attempted murder).

The Tonti Family

The Trial

Eventually Carole stood trial in December of 1983, and was found not guilty for the main charge…but guilty for the charge of arson and attempted arson and sentenced to two and a half years in prison.

However, the judge realized that she had been in jail for quite some time leading up to the trial, and decided to release her once proceedings had finished.

Unfortunately, numerous newspapers throughout Europe caught onto the case, and began publishing stories of Carole labeled as the ‘nanny witch’.

Carole now lives with her husband and children in Yorkshire and rarely talks about the incidents that happened in Italy.

Do you think that Carole was somehow linked to the occult – that she was indeed a witch?

Maybe poltergeist activity was following Carole Compton around Italy?

Please leave your thoughts and opinions in the comment section below.

6 thoughts on “Was Carole Compton a Witch?

  1. Hi,

    Quite interesting story to read about Carol Compton,

    Thanks for sharing this article, I didn’t know about this story before, but it’s good to read your article as its written from a good point, not taking any point and just given the facts that happened to Carol Compton in Italy.

    I guess she had terrible time with those two families in Italy, as you end the story, we don’t know if that was just  poltergeist activity or just that something happened when she was living with the families in Italy, 

    Quite interesting website you have here, I will go now and read more of your articles. 

    1. Cool – glad you like the website and the article Alejandra! Enjoy the rest of the cases we’ve covered here (and chip in with your own opinion when you see fit!)

  2. This is a very interesting story. 

    To call Carole Compton a witch might be a bit far fetched. Maybe we should follow the judges, and call her an arsonist which she obviously was. 

    If she is now living happily with her family, bringing up this story again might be upsetting for her. Do you think this is right? 

    1. I’m pretty sure we’re not the only website online to bring up this story Alenka, so I won’t be losing any sleep over it! 

  3. Dear Friend,

    Few years before I came across the case of Carole Compton and watched few videos about Carole Compton and your post provided new insights on Carole Compton. As you know very well often things are manipulated online so its very difficult to come to a conclusion based on what we learn from the internet.

    I believe she is the author of the book Superstition: The True Story of the Nanny They Called a Witch. If we read hear book we will get more insights.

    May I ask have you read her book?

    Wishing you great success!


    1. I haven’t no Paul – but I’m very interested in doing so now! Thanks for bringing it to my attention – it’ll make a great subject to cover further in an article here!!! 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *